top of page



Concept or Theory Behind this Diet:

Meal replacement

Herbalife: Company Overview, Weight Loss Program, Multilevel Marketing, Criticisms, and Controversies


Herbalife is a global nutrition and weight management company founded in 1980 by Mark Hughes. The company offers a range of products, including dietary supplements, meal replacements, and personal care items, which are sold through a network of independent distributors using a multilevel marketing (MLM) model. Herbalife has faced numerous controversies and criticisms, particularly related to its MLM business structure and the efficacy of its weight loss program. This essay will discuss Herbalife's weight loss program, the theory behind the diet, the company's MLM model, Bill Ackman's criticisms and short-selling efforts, the program's cost, and the issue of unsold inventory for distributors.

Herbalife Weight Loss Program and Diet Theory

Herbalife's weight loss program is centered around its flagship product, the Formula 1 Nutritional Shake Mix, a meal replacement shake designed to provide essential nutrients while reducing calorie intake. The program recommends replacing two meals per day with the Formula 1 shake and consuming one balanced meal alongside it. Herbalife also offers supplementary products such as protein bars, teas, and vitamin and mineral supplements to support weight loss and overall health.

The theory behind Herbalife's weight loss program is based on reducing calorie intake through portion control and meal replacement while providing essential nutrients. By replacing high-calorie meals with lower-calorie shakes, individuals can create a calorie deficit, leading to weight loss. Additionally, the program emphasizes the importance of consuming a balanced diet and engaging in regular physical activity to support long-term weight management.

Multilevel Marketing Model

Herbalife operates under an MLM business model, where independent distributors purchase products from the company at a wholesale price and sell them to customers at a retail price. Distributors earn income through retail profits, as well as commissions from the sales made by the distributors they recruit into their downline. This model encourages distributors to both sell products and recruit new members to grow their businesses.

Bill Ackman's Criticisms and Short-Selling Efforts

Infund manager Bill Ackman publicly accused Herbalife of operating as a pyramid scheme and announced a $1 billion short position in the company's stock. Ackman argued that Herbalife's MLM model was fundamentally flawed, as it relied on the recruitment of new distributors rather than focusing on selling products to end customers. He claimed that the majority of distributors earned little to no income and that the company's revenue was generated primarily through distributor investments in inventory rather than actual retail sales.

Ackman's short-selling efforts and criticisms led to increased scrutiny of Herbalife's business practices, resulting in investigations by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and other regulatory bodies. In 2016, Herbalife settled with the FTC for $200 million and agreed to restructure its business model to address concerns about its compensation system and retail sales practices.

Program Cost and Unsold Inventory

Herbalife's weight loss program can be relatively expensive for customers, as the cost of the meal replacement shakes, supplements, and other products can add up quickly. The cost of the program varies depending on the specific products purchased and the distributor's pricing.

One of the primary criticisms of Herbalife's MLM model is the issue of unsold inventory for distributors. As distributors are incentivized to purchase products in bulk to qualify for higher commission rates, many often end up with large amounts of unsold inventory. This can lead to financial losses for distributors, particularly those at the bottom of the organization, who may struggle to sell products and recruit new members.


Herbalife is a nutrition and weight management company with a long history and global presence. Its weight loss program is based on the principle of calorie reduction through meal replacements and portion control. However, the company has faced significant controversy due to its MLM business model and the criticisms levied by Bill Ackman and others.

Herbalife has had to address these issues through legal settlements and business restructuring, but concerns remain about the efficacy of its weight loss program, the cost for customers, and the challenges faced by distributors in managing inventory and earning income. Despite these challenges, Herbalife continues to operate and maintain a loyal customer base, highlighting the complexity and resilience of the company and its offerings.

bottom of page